Sharing is caring!

Garlic Butter Steak Bites with Creamy Mozzarella Rigatoni is more than a meal — it’s a cozy, skillet-seared memory dressed in garlic, butter, and love. The way the steak tips sizzle, releasing their buttery aroma, instantly takes me back to my grandmother’s kitchen, where flavor always began with a knob of butter. If you’re into seafood, you’ll appreciate that same buttery comfort found in these Garlic Butter Baked Scallops. And for steak lovers, the juicy richness reminds me of the Grilled Flank Steak with Balsamic Caprese Twist, another must-try.

This dish was born from a fridge clean-out and quickly became a weekly favorite, thanks to its tender steak, rich mozzarella sauce, and just a whisper of Cajun heat.

Subscribe now and never miss a recipe that brings warmth (and butter) to your table.

Why This Dish is Special

What makes Garlic Butter Steak Bites with Creamy Mozzarella Rigatoni truly unforgettable is the way each element supports the next. The steak isn’t just a protein—it’s the star. Tender sirloin or ribeye bites soak up garlic butter like sponges, turning every bite into a rich, savory experience. When paired with rigatoni, which perfectly holds onto that velvety mozzarella and cream sauce, the result is both comforting and indulgent.

The addition of Cajun seasoning adds a whisper of heat, balanced out by Italian herbs and the creamy dairy base. It’s that balance—bold and mellow, hearty and smooth—that elevates this from just another pasta dish to something you’ll crave weekly.

If you’re already a fan of pasta dishes that combine bold spices with a creamy finish, you’ll enjoy the depth found in this Garlic Cajun Chicken with Cheesy Mozzarella Linguine. And for something a little more veggie-forward, the Sun-Dried Tomato and Mushroom Pasta in a Garlic and Basil Sauce offers a similar creamy base with earthy twists.

Ultimately, this recipe is special because it brings restaurant-level flavor into your own kitchen—without complicated steps or fancy ingredients. It’s the kind of dish that feels like a reward at the end of a long day but comes together with pantry staples and a single skillet.

Garlic Butter Steak Bites with Creamy Mozzarella Rigatoni

 Ingredients & Preparation 

Your Ingredient Breakdown

This recipe may taste like something out of a high-end steakhouse, but you’ll be surprised how approachable the ingredients are. Everything on this list can be found at your local grocery store—and chances are, most of it is already in your kitchen.

Here’s what you’ll need:

Print

If you’re craving even more pasta-rich goodness, the Creamy Cajun Chicken Linguine uses many of these same staples for a bolder Southern twist.

And for veggie fans, the Sun-Dried Tomato and Mushroom Pasta is a flavor-packed alternative with similar creamy elements.

Tools and Easy Swaps

Tools You’ll Need:

• Cast iron or stainless-steel skillet

• Medium saucepan for boiling pasta

• Wooden spoon or spatula

• Cutting board + sharp knife

• Measuring cups and spoons

Substitution Ideas:

• No rigatoni? Use penne or rotini.

• No heavy cream? Use half-and-half but reduce the milk.

• No mozzarella? Try provolone or a mild white cheddar for a twist.

• Want leaner protein? Swap steak for boneless chicken thighs or tofu cubes.

These substitutions make this dish flexible without compromising flavor. If you’re short on time, pre-cut steak tips save several prep minutes and still brown beautifully in the skillet.

 Cooking Instructions & Tips 

Step-by-Step Cooking Method

This dish comes together in less than 40 minutes and uses just one skillet and one pot. Here’s how I do it every time for the creamiest, steak-kissed pasta.

Step 1: Cook the Rigatoni
Boil a large pot of salted water. Add rigatoni and cook until al dente, about 9–11 minutes. Drain and set aside, saving ½ cup of pasta water.

Step 2: Sear the Steak Bites
In a hot skillet over medium-high heat, add olive oil and 1 tbsp butter. Once melted, add seasoned steak tips (salt, pepper, Cajun seasoning). Sear for 2–3 minutes per side until deeply browned. Remove and set aside.

Step 3: Make the Sauce
Lower heat to medium. Add remaining butter and garlic to the skillet. Sauté for 30 seconds. Stir in cream, milk, Italian seasoning, and a pinch of red pepper flakes. Simmer for 3–4 minutes, then add mozzarella and parmesan, stirring until melted.

Step 4: Combine Everything
Add pasta to the sauce, thinning with pasta water if needed. Gently fold in steak bites. Taste and adjust seasoning. Sprinkle parsley over top.

Tips and Tricks to Perfect It

• Sear in batches to avoid steaming the meat. Crowding = soggy steak.

• Don’t skip the butter divide. The first bit browns the steak, the second builds your sauce.

• Save that pasta water! It emulsifies the sauce for a silkier texture.

• Taste everything. This dish balances spice, salt, and cream. Adjust to your preference.

This one-pan wonder gives off similar indulgent vibes to the Slow Cooker Pepper Steak with Onion Stir Fry, but with a creamy twist. If you’re more in the mood for pasta-forward comfort, the Creamy Cajun Chicken Linguine also brings that same rich, bold satisfaction.

 Serving, Storing & Pairing

What to Serve with It

Garlic Butter Steak Bites with Creamy Mozzarella Rigatoni is rich and satisfying all on its own, but the right pairings can make your meal feel like a full-on dinner experience.

I like to serve this dish with a simple green salad—something crisp and lemony to contrast the creamy pasta. Roasted asparagus or garlic sautéed green beans work beautifully too. Want bread on the table? Warm, crusty sourdough or homemade garlic knots are perfect for soaking up any extra sauce.

For something extra indulgent, try pairing it with the Cheesy Ravioli with Spinach, Mushrooms and Sun-Dried Tomatoes as a shareable side. The textures and flavors complement each other surprisingly well.

And if you’re hosting or cooking for a special night in, consider starting with a small plate of Balsamic Marinated Flank Steak with Blue Cheese Crust as an appetizer or second main. It’s bold, balanced, and elegant enough to impress.

For drinks, go with something that can handle the richness—a glass of dry red wine, lemon-infused sparkling water, or even an IPA with enough bite to cut through the cheese.

How to Store and Reheat

This dish stores beautifully and makes excellent leftovers.

To store:
Let it cool completely before transferring to an airtight container. It will stay fresh in the refrigerator for up to 3–4 days.

To reheat:
Warm gently in a skillet over medium heat with a splash of milk or water to loosen the sauce. Avoid microwaving at high power—it can overcook the steak and make the sauce separate. Use 50–60% power in short bursts if you must microwave.

You can also freeze leftovers, though the texture of the dairy-based sauce may change slightly upon thawing. If freezing, do so without the garnishes, and reheat slowly over the stove.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

 Can I use a different cut of steak for this recipe?
Yes! Sirloin or ribeye offers the best tenderness and flavor, but you can also use NY strip, filet mignon tips, or even flank steak if sliced thin. Just adjust cook time based on thickness.

 Is there a way to make this dish less rich?
Absolutely. Swap the heavy cream for half-and-half, and reduce the mozzarella slightly. You’ll still get a creamy texture, just lighter.

 Can I make this ahead of time?
You can prep the steak and even cook the pasta ahead of time. Store them separately and combine when ready to eat. Reheat gently for best results.

 Will this recipe work without Cajun seasoning?
Definitely. It adds a mild kick, but you can leave it out or substitute with smoked paprika or chili flakes for similar depth.

 What’s the best pasta alternative to rigatoni?
Penne, fusilli, or even shells work well—anything that holds onto sauce. Just avoid smooth pastas like spaghetti, which won’t grab the cream as well.

 Can I freeze leftovers?
Yes, though the cream sauce may slightly separate when thawed. Add a splash of cream or milk while reheating and stir well to bring it back together.

Conclusion 

This dish hits that sweet spot between indulgent and easy — and it’s now a regular on my weeknight rotation. Garlic Butter Steak Bites with Creamy Mozzarella Rigatoni isn’t just rich in flavor, but rich in memories too. From the sizzle of the steak to the melt of the mozzarella, every bite tells a story of comfort and good food made from the heart.

If creamy pasta is your love language, you’ll appreciate this twist on Creamy Steak Pasta from Skinny Spatula — it’s another great take on the steak-and-sauce combo, with a UK-inspired spin.

For more cozy, cheese-forward recipes, don’t miss Sylvia’s Cheesy Ravioli with Spinach, Mushrooms and Sun-Dried Tomatoes. It brings similar richness, with a veggie touch.

Whether you’re feeding your family or treating yourself, this skillet dish is bound to become a favorite.